|
Yesterday,
if Jeopardy had asked me to name the most
significant Jewish baseball player in major league
baseball history, I would have said, "Who is Sandy
Koufax?" I remember Koufax sitting out a possible
World Series start because it fell on a Jewish holiday
back in the 1960s.
Tonight I know much more
about Jews in baseball, so I now realize that the
correct Jeopardy question is "Who is Hank
Greenberg?" No white man ever suffered as much discrimination
in major league baseball, as even his hometown fans
in Detroit occasionally heaped anti-Semitic remarks
at the prolific slugger. The fans in opposing cities
and the players on opposing teams were even less
kind, yet Greenberg remained a model of decorum,
preferring to extract his “revenge” on the playing
field.
Aviva Kempner produced,
wrote, and directed this remarkable biography that
consists of numerous archival film clips and interviews
with friends, fans, family, and teammates of Greenberg.
There are even a few 1984 clips of an interview
with Greenberg that are woven so skillfully into
The Life and Times of Hank Greenberg
that you will think that Greenberg recorded it specifically
for this project. You'll get to see Greenberg smash
many home runs, miss a few pitches very badly, and
see some vintage World Series clips from 1934, 1935,
1940, and 1945 along with other baseball footage.
Even though the focus lies with Greenberg's baseball
career, the film actually covers much more ground.
Literary critic Jacques
Barzun once wrote "Whoever wants to know the
heart and mind of America had better learn baseball
..." That applies directly to The Life and Times
of Hank Greenberg. By exploring Greenberg’s life,
we learn a great deal about American life and attitudes
during the 1930s. We see an America that brutally
ostracizes and stereotypes Jews in the 1930s, then
joins together during World War II to fight fascist
regimes in Germany and Japan, and begins to accept
people from minority groups as fellow Americans
after the war. This has to be one of the most challenging
times in history for Jewish people with Hitler's
rise to power and with the infamous German-American
bund rally being held in New York City in 1939,
and the film shows us how Greenberg dealt with the
situation.
While people intensely interested
in either baseball or in Jewish history will be
the prime audience, the documentary contains some
clever entertaining touches for the more casual
fan without straying from its educational value.
For starters just listen to the Yiddish version
of "Take Me Out to the Ball Game" sung by Henry
Sapoznik. Then there are some funny exchanges with
a lady who would have been classified as a groupie
since she practically stalked Greenberg wherever
he played. Most telling is a photograph she took
of herself and Greenberg at the Florida stadium
during Spring training--it shows the young lady
in the foreground with Greenberg to her left behind
a screen. She admits that Greenberg had no idea
who she was or that he was photographed with her.
See what you think of that scene-–it gave me a few
chuckles.
There’s also some interesting
stories related by some Jewish rabbis. One tells
how Greenberg was trying to decide whether he should
play during Rosh Hoshana and sought advice from
a Detroit rabbi, who consulted the Torah very loosely
and told him that he should play. Another rabbi
explains how they would play "baseball games" with
the Torah itself, as the letters of the words all
had special meanings that they would relate to baseball
terms. Other stories are interspersed throughout
the film, but essentially all of them indicate how
highly the Jewish community thought of the only
openly Jewish ballplayer in the major leagues in
the 1930s and 1940s.
Not that there hadn't been
other Jewish players, but they had disguised their
names. When the film mentions this, we are immediately
dispensed to a clip of Gregory Peck's 1947 film
Gentleman's Agreement where he attempts to get a
hotel room registered as "Mr. Green." Peck is denied
a room because he is Jewish – the disguised name
doesn't help. Other film clips are used effectively
as well, including a few from Pride of the
Yankees and a clip from a Tracy – Hepburn
film that parallels the ignorance of Greenberg’s
first wife about baseball.
I know that I learned a
great deal from this film, and wish I'd seen this
before going to the Hall of Fame where Greenberg
is suitably enshrined. I knew that Greenberg was
the first player to challenge Babe Ruth's landmark
60 home run season record in 1938 when he slammed
58, but I had no idea of his importance to Jewish
people. He was a real hero to many Jewish people,
as exemplified with the remembrances of Michigan
Senator Carl Levin and Representative Sander Levin
– you can feel their increased energy when they
enthusiastically discuss their boyhood hero. Even
Walter Mathau tells how he joined a tennis club
that Greenberg belonged to just so he could meet
his hero and have lunches; Walter admits that he
doesn't even play tennis!
The Life and Times
of Hank Greenberg is an enjoyable gem of
a film – the best sports related documentary I've
seen this side of When We Were Kings
and Hoop Dreams because it actually
does much more than illuminate one man. Through
its carefully researched and selected film clips,
it reveals a great deal about what America was all
about in the 1930s and 1940s. This will be a difficult
film to find in most of the country, as it will
be relegated to a few art houses, but if you are
a baseball fan, are Jewish, or enjoy learning about
American history during this particular generation,
seek this film out. You won't be disappointed.
|