|
Whenever
you see a Robert Altman film, you expect to see
certain trademark touches--overlapping images and
sounds, a large cast of characters, some excellent
actors doing improvisational work, a loosely constructed
tapestry. In his better films you'll even be challenged
to figure out what the film is about, and such is
the case with Nashville.
The film serves as a parody
of country music, a biting satire of American politics,
a critique of American society, or a combination
of any of these. Some creative English major could
even make a case for Nashville
being about God and the Devil, and draw parallels
to Moby Dick if you want
to really stretch it. If you seek the definitive
answer from screenwriter Joan Tewksbury, you'll
only get a confirmation that you can see any of
the above (though I think the off the wall English
major idea would give her a laugh). That’s what
she told those of us attending a 25th anniversary
screening of the Altman classic at the Scottsdale
Film Festival in early 2002.
Remarkably, Altman left
Tewksbury’s 175-page script intact, as it essentially
parallels her real life trip to Nashville over a
five-day period. Basked in red, white, and blue,
the campaign van of imaginary Replacement Party
candidate Hal Phillip Walker emerges from a parking
garage, and we hear the ever present loudspeakers
remind us that all of us are political creatures—"All of us are deeply involved with politics
whether we know it or not and whether we like it
or not." Immediately we apply this to the 24 major
characters we encounter along the way, and we witness
the pattern of required protocols and sexual politics
that prevail in Altman's microcosm of American society.
There are numerous threads
to follow -- each of the 24 characters weaves his/her
way through the plot, interconnecting along the
way until all 24 congregate at the Parthenon for
the final rally. In some weird co-incidences, this
is the spot where Al Gore almost conceded on election
night, and check out the references that Hal Phillip
Walker makes over the loudspeakers. He talks about
limiting the power of rich Texas oil interests and
eliminating the Electoral College. Additionally,
his question of "Does Christmas smell like oranges
to you?" takes on Florida connotations in the crazy
2000 electoral year.
Everyone will find certain
threads more interesting than others, but the main
one follows a Loretta Lynn-styled country queen,
Barbara Jean (Ronee Blakley) whose unstable health
continually borders on the brink of a nervous breakdown.
One of the film's highlights occurs when Barbara
Jean begins telling pointless rambling stories instead
of breaking into song. It's a scene that provokes
an uneasy laughter because we grow to sympathize
with the Barbara Jean who sings from her country
soul. Reflecting on her life, we can imagine what
it has to be like to create a hit song from your
heart and be required to sing it every day for your
adoring fans.
That doesn't seem to bother
Haven Hamilton (Henry Gibson), who will appear on
any stage that Barbara Jean performs on. A supreme
egotist, Hamilton hangs in all the required Nashville
country music spots and continues to bang out his
"hits" to "Keep a Goin’," yet he does come through
in the final scene with some real compassion.
Hamilton's song "For the
Sake of the Children" could be Linnea Reese's (Lily
Tomlin's) theme song, as she is saddled with a wretched
marriage with a cold hearted husband (Ned Beatty)
who doesn't relate to his children and later makes
a pass at another woman. The telling scene shows
her deaf son sharing his swimming experience, with
Tomlin listening and caring intently while her husband
remains bored and clueless.
The most clueless character
prize has to go to Geraldine Chaplin's character,
Opal. Can this obnoxious, shallow interviewer really
work for the BBC? Perhaps, if they just wanted to
get her out of the country. Some of the film's most
humorous scenes take place with Opal touring auto
junkyards and school bus yards searching for metaphors.
Usually she is found barging into private conversations
or interrupting people with her ubiquitous recording
microphone.
Close behind Opal in cluelessness
is Sueleen Gay (Gwen Welles), a waitress from the
lower classes who has come to Nashville to become
the next Barbara Jean. Unfortunately, she has to
rank right next to Drew Barrymore as the worst singer
to ever hit the screen. (Woody Allen dubbed in another
singer for Barrymore, but Altman leaves Welles'
voice intact)
Mixed in is Mr. Green (Keenan
Wynn) with his dying wife, whose platform-shoe-and-hot-pants-wearing
California niece (Shelley Duvall) relentlessly pursues
every available two-legged man she can find, including
a troubled Ohio drifter (David Hayward) and Pfc.
Glenn Kelly (Scott Glenn), who worships and protects
Barbara Jean from afar. There's also a folk rock
trio, a Charley Pride-type singer, a New Mexico
redneck trying to find his wife, who aspires to
be a recording star, and several other characters.
The sheer number of protagonists
may intimidate some viewers, and I'm sure that many
are turned off by the way Altman switches from character
to character as each fades in from the background
into the foreground before retreating. However,
the sheer force of the great scenes should keep
even more casual viewers tuned in.
Like the city of Nashville
itself, screenwriter Tewksbury structures the plot
in a circular pattern, as this is the way she experienced
the city. People you'd see in certain "in" diners
at lunch time would show up later at the Grand Ole
Opry or race track and then again in a local night
club. In time a synergistic community emerges, as
it does in this film. Still, certain scenes just
stand out and beg for re-watching even if you have
difficulty following the overall plot. Everything
that Lily Tomlin does bears close watching in this
film, from her participation with the gospel choir,
to her loving interactions with her deaf kids, to
the brief affair she submits to with folk-rock singer
Tom (Keith Carradine). Other favorites include:
- One of the most creative
opening credits sequences ever, as it mirrors
those fast talking television ads for music compilation
albums.
- Geraldine Chaplin "listening"
to a heartfelt personal song by Buddy Hamilton
(David Peel), only to exclaim "It's Elliott Gould"
and run off.
- A gut-wrenching scene
with Keenan Wynn after he discovers his wife has
died, and an exuberant Scott Glenn talks with
him about Barbara Jean's hospital release.
- The singing scenes with
both Ronee Blakley and Karen Black. These actresses
could have second careers as country artists!
- The incredible scene
with Keith Carradine singing "I'm Easy" where
four women all believe that he is singing his
life story to them. Only Lily Tomlin is correct,
which leads to another great scene that intimately
reveals both of their characters – Tomlin's overriding
loyalty to her children and Carradine's extreme
melancholy and loneliness.
- Gwen Welles' disillusionment
when she discovers that she has been hired to
strip. Her character may be limited, but she makes
us laugh and feel compassion for her simultaneously
as she awkwardly begins to strip, surprisingly
tossing out a pair of socks she had used for padding
Of course there are others,
but that's why Nashville requires
multiple viewings. Altman's trademark overlapping
dialogue and imagery allows you to focus on different
aspects, so the film remains fresh each time you
see it.
I'm not sure that Altman
would edit his film exactly the same way if he were
doing this for a modern audience. Altman did cut
his original 4-hour version down to a 2 hour 40
minute film, but he still retains entire songs throughout
the film. I'm sure this is out of respect for the
actors, who all performed and wrote their own songs,
but some of them are rather lame and could be improved
with some massive cutting. (I'm thinking mostly
of Henry Gibson’s material)
One song that absolutely
must remain intact is Carradine's Oscar winning
"I'm Easy." The Academy did its usual job of overlooking
brilliant work, as Carradine's Oscar was the lone
winner. Joan Tewksbury's outstanding screenplay
was completely overlooked and failed to score a
nomination. Perhaps the Academy felt that it was
90% improvisation from Altman's reputation, not
realizing that very little of Tewksbury’s script
was fully improvised.
After it's over, most everyone
has a question that basically asks what was this
movie about? (There's a more specific question that
I won't reveal just in case you haven't seen the
film or heard about the ending). This is one film
that is so dense that you can explore it at various
levels. If you're confused, that's no problem. That
fits right in with the American system, as Walker's
loudspeaker blares over the other dialog:
"Who do you
think is running Congress? Farmers? Engineers? Teachers?
Businessmen? No, my friends. Congress is run by
lawyers. A lawyer is trained for two things and
two things only. To clarify -– that's one. And to
confuse--that's the other thing."
As Nashville's
plot evolves, it progresses from being lighthearted
to a darker tone. This occurs both with the scenery
and the plot elements themselves, all symbolic of
a place that is losing its innocence. In politics,
America has just gone through the Watergate affair
with Nixon resigning during Nashville’s
filming. Simultaneously, country music was transitioning
from its old home with Minnie Pearl and String Bean
in the old Opry House to a brand spanking new one
designed to bring in bigger bucks. As long as we
have politics and country music going, Nashville
will remain relevant as a microcosm of America and
its people.
Note: A few tidbits from
screenwriter Joan Tewkesbury:
- Tewkesbury identifies
with the Geraldine Chaplin character. She was
like her during her research for the film –- just
not as talkative or obnoxious.
- The script really was
left largely intact, but actors could write their
own lines and submit them to Tewksbury. Scott
Glenn, Keenan Wynn, and Gwen Welles only did what
was scripted, but Geraldine Chaplin wrote all
of her ludicrous metaphors in the junkyard and
busyard.
- Keith Carradine had written
his two songs well before the film began.
- No actor was required
to write his/her own songs, but it became almost
like a competition to do so. Henry Gibson and
David Arkin seemed to be in competition for writing
the most ludicrous songs.
- Louise Fletcher was originally
cast for the role that Lily Tomlin played, and
originally the character had deaf parents (true
to Fletcher's real life). However, Fletcher had
to bow out of the production because of a scheduling
conflict -– she was filming One Flew Over
the Cuckoo’s Nest.
- Ronee Blakley was really
burned as a child as described in the script.
|